A book about notebooks: “The infinite potential of the blank page”

(Image: Roland-Allen.com)

During the pandemic, I found myself resorting to printed notebooks to jot down ideas and impressions, write mini-essays, develop plans, and make lists. I think I was getting so tired of living my life online that I became specially drawn to the analog appeal of deploying pen and paper for recording my thoughts. 

As for the notebooks themselves, I went both highbrow and budget level, using both pricey Moleskine books and inexpensive Mead composition books. I tended to write the more “profound” stuff in the Moleskines, while putting everyday notes and numbers into the composition books.

Today, I’ve kept up the notebook habit, especially for brainstorming over potential projects, developing ideas, and planning for the coming weeks, months, and years. I feel like I’m in a mental comfort zone when I’m in this notebook writing mode.

***

It should be no wonder, then, that I was delighted to discover Roland Allen’s marvelous The Notebook, A History of Thinking on Paper (2023). The book’s title doubles as its description. Allen chronicles in fascinating detail how both prominent and everyday people have used notebooks or their historical predecessors, going back to the days of stone tablets.

Allen’s long introduction starts us in the present, exploring the Moleskine notebook phenomenon and the underlying draw of this brand and others in our digital age. It reassured me that I have not been alone in experiencing the attraction of printed notebooks, even if in some ways it’s easier for us to simply open our laptops and start typing away.

In trying to nail down that appeal, the caption accompanying a photo of a modern notebook explained the heart of it for me: “The infinite potential of the blank page.” Awesome.

 

On studying the “Great Books” at the University of Chicago: A deeply satisfying finish and a glorious failure

Certificate and graduation program

During June, I made a quick trip to Chicago to attend my graduation ceremony from the University of Chicago’s storied Basic Program of Liberal Education for Adults. The Basic Program is an open enrollment, non-credit, four-year sequence of courses featuring the close reading and discussion of what have been called the Great Books. It starts with works by ancient Greek philosophers and poets and proceeds to examine other canonical authors and works of the Western tradition. The Basic Program is offered through the U of C’s Graham School of Continuing Liberal and Professional Studies, one of the University’s three original academic units, dating back to its founding in the early 1890s.

The Basic Program has been a long-time Graham School staple, solidly rooted in the Great Books movement championed by the likes of U of C President Robert Hutchins, Columbia University professor John Erskine, and iconoclastic educator Mortimer Adler during the early and mid 20th century. Traditionally offered in a small group, in-person format in the Chicagoland area, the Basic Program began piloting an online version during the years preceding the pandemic. When COVID arrived, everything moved online.

The pandemic had prompted me to search for interactive, online learning opportunities that might soften the isolation of spending so much time at home. I had known about the Basic Program for many years, but I assumed it would remain an in-person offering only. However, I wondered if the pandemic had prompted a change, and it had indeed. I would enroll in the Fall of 2020.

As I wrote on this blog in early 2021, reading some of the important works that comprised the Basic Program curriculum had long been on my radar screen, but I knew that I couldn’t do it alone:

I can be a person of contradictions. I have long resisted required courses and curricula at just about every stage of learning in my life, going back to grade school. If a subject doesn’t interest me, then I don’t want to sink any time into it.

But here I am, delighted to participate in a four-year, prescribed curriculum of courses and books.

You see, I have long wanted to read the classics of the Western tradition, considering this to be a big gap in my education. To the extent that I have a “bucket list,” reading these works has been on it.

The problem is that I’m just not self-disciplined enough to read the Great Books on my own. They require a sustained, concentrated commitment. Although I don’t need the prod of tests and quizzes, I do need the presence of a teacher and fellow learners, along with a set schedule.

That’s exactly what the Basic Program provides. The instructors are dedicated, gifted teachers in the Socratic tradition, and they facilitate dialogues among very bright fellow students who are excited about participating in this course of study.

In a notebook that I kept during 2020-21 to record assorted thoughts, ideas, and plans, I jotted down why I wished to undertake this considerable investment of time and attention. I concluded, with a somewhat dramatic, self-important flourish, that “I want to be an educated man.” I figured that four years of immersive study of the Great Books, guided and inspired by Basic Program instructors and fellow students, would help me achieve that objective.

Graduation

I will be writing more about the intellectual substance of being in this program later. But for now, let me fast forward back to the point where I’m in Chicago last month for our graduation festivities. Our weekend was a deeply satisfying way to finish the four-year journey, the 74th graduation ceremony in the Basic Program’s history. It was such a delight to meet many of my instructors and classmates in person for the very first time, after spending literally hundreds of hours together on Zoom.

We started with a Saturday dinner for our cohort, hosted by one of our classmates. Sunday morning and afternoon included an opening breakfast hosted by the Basic Program for donors to the class gift, followed by the graduation ceremony itself, and then an informal lunch with several classmates.

Although our online cohort of some 14-15 students greatly enjoyed each others’ contributions to our class discussions and had developed a genuine rapport, it remained to be seen how we would interact when we got together in-person for the first time. It turned out that we had little to worry about on that note. Graduation weekend was like meeting old friends.

Glorious failure

The Basic Program started as a welcomed and engaging focal point during the heart of the pandemic. It finished as a rewarding intellectual and personal experience, spent in the good company of a very special group of fellow learners and instructors.

But in one way, it was a glorious failure. Recall my notebook jotting that I wanted to enroll in the program to become “an educated man.” During our final quarter together and continuing into our graduation weekend, I found myself pondering that original objective. I realized that the greatest intellectual gift of the Basic Program was that it constituted a jumpstart, not a finish, to my education. 

Indeed, during these four years, I was constantly reminded of how much I didn’t know, thanks in part to my responses to our assigned readings, but mostly due to the richness of our class discussions and insights shared by others in the room. I can’t even begin to count how many times someone’s thoughtful comment, pointed observation, or shared piece of knowledge led me to think, omigosh, I wouldn’t have thought of that in a million years.

And so, I find myself looking forward to more learning adventures, including additional classes through the Graham School. They will provide rewards as sheer intellectual experiences, as well as lenses for examining contemporary life. In fact, the experience of this program has led me to conclude that deep reading and contemplation of important works can help us understand the unsettling and illiberal (i.e., intolerant and narrow-minded) condition of our broader society today. I’ll be sharing a few of those lessons in future postings.

Free online event: “The Dignity of an Intellectual Life for All,” Oct. 21, 1-3 pm.

The Dignity of an Intellectual Life for All

Friday, October 21, 2022, 1:00-3:00 p.m., Eastern Time, Online Format

Hosted by Suffolk University Law School (https://www.suffolk.edu/law/) and co-sponsored by:

Basic Program of Liberal Education for Adults, University of Chicago, Graham School https://graham.uchicago.edu/programs-courses/basic-program)

Harrison Middleton University (https://www.hmu.edu)

World Dignity University Initiative of Human Dignity and Humiliation Studies (https://www.worlddignityuniversity.org)

With a focus on Dr. Zena Hitz’s thought-provoking book, Lost in Thought: The Hidden Pleasures of an Intellectual Life (2020), this program will examine the value of embracing the liberal arts and humanities for their own sake and consider how a rich intellectual life for everyone enhances human dignity. The program opens with a conversation featuring Dr. Hitz, followed by a responsive panel comprised of four distinguished educators, with opportunities for Q&A.

Featured Speaker

Zena Hitz, Tutor, St. John’s College, Annapolis, MD, and author, Lost in Thought: The Hidden Pleasures of an Intellectual Life (Princeton, NJ: Princeton U. Press, 2020)  https://zenahitz.net

Guest Panelists

Joseph Coulson, President, Harrison Middleton University   https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joseph_Coulson

Hilda Demuth-Lutze, English teacher (ret.), Chesterton High School, IN, and author of historical fiction                                               https://kingdomofthebirds.wordpress.com/about-the-author/

Amy Thomas Elder, Instructor, Basic Program of Liberal Education for Adults, University of Chicago, Graham School                https://graham.uchicago.edu/person/amy-thomas-elder

Linda Hartling, Director, Human Dignity and Humiliation Studies  https://www.humiliationstudies.org/whoweare/linda.php

Moderator

David Yamada, Professor of Law, Suffolk University Law School, Boston, MA https://www.suffolk.edu/academics/faculty/d/y/dyamada

UPDATE: A freely accessible recording of this very engaging program has now been posted to YouTube. Go here to watch it!

2022 side gig: Serving as a “Fellow in Ideas” at Harrison Middleton University

This year, I’m delighted to be doing an important “side gig” endeavor as a 2022 “Fellow in Ideas” at Harrison Middleton University (HMU), an online university devoted exclusively to the exploration of Great Books and Great Ideas.  Those selected as Fellows contribute reviews and essays to HMU’s publications and join in various discussion groups.

So far, my participation has included:

I look forward to taking part in more HMU activities to round out my fellowship experience during the fall.

Harrison Middleton University is a unique educational entity. Its strongest intellectual roots trace back to Great Books of the Western World, a series of books first published by the Encyclopedia Britannica in 1952, comprised mostly of full works by selected authors of the Western canon. HMU has obtained national accreditation through the Distance Education Accrediting Commission (DEAC). Whereas many DEAC-accredited members are for-profit institutions emphasizing vocational preparation, HMU is a non-profit, online university devoted solely to the liberal arts.

HMU’s work is especially needed during a time when independent inquiry, liberal learning, and the Great Books are on the decline in much of standard-brand higher education and under attack from the social and political extremes. It is a gift to be a year-long visitor to this stimulating, intelligent, and welcoming community.